Which of these two controversial winners would you enjoy more on a returnee season?
These two back to back winners have often been the ire of many fans (for very different reasons), but I think that a return from either of them would actually be quite nice to see! Chris Underwood certainly benefitted from Edge of Extinction, but he's proven on The Challenge to be quite the fierce competitor. I think him returning and making it far would be a nice redemption arc for him. Tommy meanwhile, is heavily lauded by fans for his heavy handed and obvious winner edit. On a new season, Tommy can actually get a balanced edit and possibly prove that his strong social game wasn't a fluke, and cement himself as a top tier player and winner. I turn it over to you guys though; which of these two would you get more out of if they were to return?
These two back to back winners have often been the ire of many fans (for very different reasons), but I think that a return from either of them would actually be quite nice to see! Chris Underwood certainly benefitted from Edge of Extinction, but he's proven on The Challenge to be quite the fierce competitor. I think him returning and making it far would be a nice redemption arc for him. Tommy meanwhile, is heavily lauded by fans for his heavy handed and obvious winner edit. On a new season, Tommy can actually get a balanced edit and possibly prove that his strong social game wasn't a fluke, and cement himself as a top tier player and winner. I turn it over to you guys though; which of these two would you get more out of if they were to return?