Garrison Help

So I gave up on making 7777 orcs myself and have turned to stealing them from online sieges. I have come across a lot of the same orcs and have recruited some of them. Some of them multiple times but they don’t always show up in my Garrison.

I have multiple Maku the fixer and multiple bubol the scorpions but it won’t add multiple Hoglick(?). One siege I recruited like 8 orcs but some were repeats so only 4 went to my garrison.

If anyone has any insight that would be a huge help