Which one should i get? First pic is from amazon, second is from suzahdi.

I really want Arthur's jacket by Barking Irons but because it's really expensive to buy off of ebay, i'm thinking of either the one off of amazon (first pic) or this replica i found that's made by suzahdi (second pic). I've heard that the amazon one is really poor quality but the reviews seem alright. The suzahdi one has good reviews and suzahdi seems to make good jackets in general.