Series discussion I want to talk about all thissss!

So totally got sucked into this show but I just can’t really understand some of the reasoning. Also I can’t buy that Leni was the bad one and Gina was innocent.

Like yes I get that maybe Leni was jealous of Dylan when they were teens but SO WAS GINA of Jack. Leni shared her connection with Jack so Gina didn’t feel “left out”. So for me GINA started all this shit.

So maybe Leni wasn’t really jealous of Dylan but pissed off because Gina coerced her into sharing the love of her life with her (Jack) and as soon as Gina was falling in love she “wanted to be her own person”.

What happened to Leni when she was a kid really fucked her up and is so sad actually, but why did the dad think it was Gina who saw?? Assumed because it was “Gina” that pushed their other sister?? Also I’m unconvinced of which pushed and who was who at any point it feels like she said she said.

Charlie: I definitely feel like HE murdered Dylan and I knowwww that wasn’t what was said or how they set it up but it would make wayyyy more sense than Leni setting herself up, like why wouldn’t she make sure he was dead? Why call ahead so the mom knew? Like there is no way she could be that dumb but also be able to trick people for years.

I really did feel like all Leni did was try to protect Gina but then at the end??? She wants to drown her? I don’t believe it even if she did see that happen. Also, why wouldn’t she be the one who wanted to leave that town after she seen her dad do that?

The end??? Why on earth would Gina ever come back if she wanted out, she didn’t care about Charlie enough to care what happened after she left. She was ready to have a family and run away with Dylan. And Leni? Why would she too as a wanted murderer and to see a man who obviously loved her sister more.