Guilt: The Song keeps me up at night. Anyone else?

It's so fucking scary. It creeps me out in a way only a few other songs do (Sandy Fishnets by Evelyn Evelyn and Missed Me by The Dresden Dolls, mainly.) The more I listen, the more the surreal lyrics scare me. I think the worst part is the first verse, especially the way Sean's voice cracks on the line "And there was a hook attached to it/ and they were attached at the hip," but the whole first verse gives me the Willies. The random scream at the beginning of the second verse creeps me out, and then the confusing discordant guitar solo at the end. Does anyone else react to this song in the same way, and if you do, which parts?