[Product Request] Best cleanser for sensitive combination skin to remove dirt?

This is the current facial cleanser I use and have been using consistently for the past few years. I cleanse in circular motion 🧼 for 60 seconds ⏰.

When I go in w my cotton pad to tone after cleansing, there’s dirt all on the pad. I’m not understanding why this is the case? I’ve tried oil cleansing (dry face, dry hands 60secs) and would emulsify it afterwards (use water and then 15 secs after finishing rubbing), but still broke out.

Any suggestions on cleansers?

This is the current facial cleanser I use and have been using consistently for the past few years. I cleanse in circular motion 🧼 for 60 seconds ⏰.

When I go in w my cotton pad to tone after cleansing, there’s dirt all on the pad. I’m not understanding why this is the case? I’ve tried oil cleansing (dry face, dry hands 60secs) and would emulsify it afterwards (use water and then 15 secs after finishing rubbing), but still broke out.

Any suggestions on cleansers?