Wedding makeup

I was quoted a lot for an airbrush makeup artist who is apparently super sought-after, travels internationally for weddings, and is considered top-tier. I was expecting magic. Instead, I got a yellow, uneven mess that made me look older than I am. (First pic.)

I ended up scrambling last minute to find a new artist, and thankfully, the one who stepped in did an amazing job. (Second pic.)

The original artist still expects me to pay the full amount—even though I canceled a month before the wedding and already paid for the trial. Is this fair? Would you pay in this situation?