Mascara recommendations?

I currently have the Glossier Lash Slick but I’ve had it since last summer and I think it’s drying out, despite my attempts to re-wet it with saline and heat it before use. I’m looking for something that is very lengthening but doesn’t clump, I don’t like the volumizing mascara because it looks unnatural. I’m looking for something that is like the lash slick but maybe different. My budget is $20.