Should I get 23 or 24?

Wanted to get a baseball game, was going to get 24 but should I just get 23 ill just be playing everything by myself single player.

I was playing 20 last year and still having a good time playing diamond dynasty by myself, so if I picked up last year's game would playing DD still be enjoyable

Are there any modes that are better or worse, which version would I be better off going with ?

Also if I get 23 I was also going to pick up Alan Wake 2 so thats another factor