Can’t decide between a 458 and a 488…?!?

I’m debating on my next car and always had my eyes set on a 458. But now I’m seeing the 488 is around the same price roughly and years newer and updated. Obviously different cars but I’m curious how people like them. I hear a lot saying the 458 is the choice? How is maintenance and reliability on both? Anything specific to look out for? Neeed help to narrow my search down!!

Side note: I’ve had a lot of cars but never of this caliber. From bmw Ms to Mercedes Amg and Porsches. But I always had a dream to own a Ferrari and more recently a Lamborghini. But as a kid I always said Ferrari would be first before any lambo and I’m sticking to it.