Some guys arguing about Gnosticism. Who's right?

Edit: This is solved. No need to reply. Thanks again to cmbwriting for the gnosis.

Was on r/areweinhell and saw this post which then sparked this debate. I don't know enough about Gnosticism to judge the victor but I'm leaning towards the OP (Hemlock) after watching a few Youtube videos about the topic that support what he's saying. The "Green" dude seems pretty certain on his side but I'm not finding anything to support what he's saying. Are they just arguing two different interpretations or maybe two different branches of Gnosticism? Just curious.