What is everyone’s thoughts on Caleb Williams?

The narrative on Caleb Williams this year has been crazy to me. Caleb by no means has been balling out but he is having a genuinely solid rookie season. Does he take too many sacks? Yes. Does he try to extend plays and be a hero on plays that should be a check down? Yes. Does he miss some easy throws? Yes. Is he a ROOKIE QB? YES. It’s like he is supposed to be a top 5 qb in people’s eyes. As a Caleb owner in a dynasty league I have watched every game and although it’s been rough he has shown so many flashes of elite talent. I am not sure what his value would be in a trade right now but it seems like he gets unwarranted hate, what does everyone else think he’s worth?