Need Help Choosing Diamond

I am in between 3 diamonds. I have been ring shopping with my girlfriend and we’ve decided on this setting and she wants a 1ct natural diamond. I was going to go bigger but she’s very petite and wants 1ct. I have the following three I am in between. She loved the Costco wings which were VS2 I but didn’t have the one we wanted. I’ve created the following three with James Allen. Which would you choose?