Chaccoben Maya Ruins in Costa Maya or Chicken Itza from Cozumel?

So me and my (by then) wife will be going in honeymoon on a cruise departing from port canaveral and hitting both Costa maya and Cozumel.

We were wondering which of these two trips would be better since we only want to do one of the two. Pricewise they are pretty similar (137 for chaccoben and 164 for chicken itza but the first one is a 4 hour excursion opposed to a 9h one)

Chicken itza is the most famous of the two but I was considering the other one for time reasons and to try other excursions in Cozumel

Do you have any pointers?