Broadway Trip April 2-5

Hey all. I use to live in NYC and use to see shows all the time. I've since moved and I am coming back for a little theater trip (and to see Kylie Minogue at MSG). My question is, I use to have a TDF membership and would see shows all the time. Should I re-up my membership to see some shows? Or how have the rushes/lotteries been? I'm mostly interested in Maybe Happy Ending and Sunset and already have tickets to see Titus in "Oh, Mary."