Help! My Favorite Pillow Skyrocketed in Price—Need a Cheap, Mushy Alternative

I used to swear by the Walmart Serta Endless Comfort pillow—it was my holy grail. Super soft, super squishy, perfect for a stomach sleeper like me. And best of all? It was $10 (last time I bought it was in 2023).

Now? $35 PER PILLOW. Absolutely ridiculous. I can’t justify that price, no matter how much I loved it.

So now I’m on the hunt for a replacement. I need the softest, mushiest pillow possible—basically something that feels like a cloud and completely compresses when I lay on it. No firm support, no overstuffed loft, just pure squish.

Anyone have recommendations for something similar that won’t break the bank?