BSG Episode Breakdown / Day 6 / Most Forgettable

🥇 1st Place: Crossroads, Part 2

• 🔢 Mentions: 1 (implicit, but prominent)
• 🔼 Total Upvotes: 84
• 💬 Why it wins:
  • The sudden reveal of the Final Five
  • Jimi Hendrix’s All Along the Watchtower in a space opera
  • Tonal whiplash from courtroom drama to psychedelic awakening
• 🌀 Vibe: “What the frak just happened?” meets 2001: A Space Odyssey with electric guitars

🥈 2nd Place: The Plan (TV Movie)

• 🔢 Mentions: 5
• 🔼 Total Upvotes: 73
  • Strong support across multiple top comments
  • Viewers consistently baffled by its retcon-heavy and Cylon-centric framing
  • Unexpected nudity, tonal inconsistency, and it undermines the title's original meaning
• 🌀 Vibe: “Weird fan edit” energy with unintended comedy

🥉 3rd Place: Someone to Watch Over Me

• 🔢 Mentions: 4
• 🔼 Total Upvotes: 37
  • Kara’s dreamlike piano scenes with her possible Cylon-dad
  • Musical cues triggering Hera’s projection powers
  • Ambiguous metaphysical departure
• 🌀 Vibe: Melancholy, surreal, emotionally bizarre

This one was a little harder to figure out since we didn't have the title for the reveal of the final five - but overall that was the one that resonated with everyone as tonally off. Fitting, I suppose.

Now this category will be hard - most forgettable.