AE1 low Sizing

When I tried them on in person, the size 11 felt like a perfect fit—snug, like a glove. However, I was worried about potential toe impact and comfort during gameplay, so I went with the 11.5 as a middle ground.

The 11.5 fits well overall, but there’s about a quarter-inch of space in the toe box from my big toe to the end of the shoe. It also feels a bit tight around my big toenail, which is a little uncomfortable. I know the AE1s taper inward more than the Ja 1s (though not as extreme), so I’m not sure if this is just how they’re designed or if I should consider sizing down.

Should I stick with the 11.5 and see how they break in, or would going down to an 11 be a better move? Any advice or experiences with the AE1s would be super helpful!